Agoda Preferred
tooltip

Agoda Preferred recommends trusted and verified properties that have a long-standing relationship with Agoda and meet certain criteria.

Best Western Plus Island Palms Hotel & Marina

3 stars out of 5
tooltip

Gold star ratings are provided by the property to reflect the comfort, facilities, and amenities you can expect.

2051 Shelter Island Drive, San Diego Intl. Airport, San Diego (CA), United States, 92106-3105

Highlights

Location

Awesome location, just wish it included breakfast
Great Swimming pool

The pool and hot tub were great as well.
Well-appointed bathrooms

Large bathroom with walk in shower.
Excellent hot spring

The pool and hot tub were great as well.
Highly-rated bar

Facilities

Free Wi-Fi

Swimming pool

Car park

Spa

Front desk [24-hour]

Fitness center

Restaurants

Bar

About us

Get your trip off to a great start with a stay at this property, which offers free Wi-Fi in all rooms. Conveniently situated in the San Diego Intl. Airport part of San Diego (CA), this property puts you close to attractions and interesting dining options. Don't leave before paying a visit to the famous San Diego Zoo. Rated with 3 stars, this high-quality property provides guests with access to massage, restaurant and hot tub on-site.

This property is in high demand!

5 travelers have booked today.

Location 9.2
Cleanliness 8.9
Service 8.9
Facilities 8.7

Based on 213 verified reviews

Location

9.2

Cleanliness

8.9

Service

8.9

Facilities

8.7

Value for money

8.6

Room comfort and qua...

7.3

See map

9.2Exceptional

Location rating score

Exceptional location
Parking
Available
Popular landmarks
USS Midway Museum
4.9 km
Seaport Village
5.3 km
Old Town San Diego State Historic Park
5.4 km
SeaWorld
5.7 km
Petco Park
6.7 km
Closest landmarks
Humphreys Concerts by the Bay
400 m
Japanese Friendship Bell
840 m
Americas Cup Harbor
880 m
YOLO Board San Diego
920 m
Harbor and Shelter Islands
960 m

Good to know

Value for money8.6
Location rating9.2
Nearest airportSan Diego International Airport (SAN) - United States
Distance to airport3.9 km

Rooms available at Best Western Plus Island Palms Hotel & Marina

1 King Bed, Nonsmoking
...
  • Room size: 20 m²/215 ft²
  • 1 king bed
  • 1 king bed
Enter dates to see prices
Casa Marina Room with 2 Queen Beds - No Smoking
...
  • Room size: 20 m²/215 ft²
  • 2 queen beds
  • 2 queen beds
Enter dates to see prices
Suite - 2 Queen Beds, Nonsmoking, Marina View, Full Kitchen, Living Room, Patio, Sofabed
...
  • Room size: 55 m²/592 ft²
  • Marina view
  • 2 queen beds and 1 sofa bed
Enter dates to see prices
Suite - 1 King Bed, Nonsmoking, Casa Del Mar Building, Marina View, Two Rooms, Sofabed
...
  • Room size: 20 m²/215 ft²
  • Marina view
  • 1 sofa bed and 1 king bed
Enter dates to see prices
Suite - 2 Queen Beds, Nonsmoking, Scenic View, Living Room, Full Kitchen, Sofabed
...
  • Room size: 55 m²/592 ft²
  • 2 queen beds and 1 sofa bed
  • 2 queen beds and 1 sofa bed
Enter dates to see prices
1 King Bed, Nonsmoking, Casa Marina Building, Water View
...
  • Room size: 28 m²/301 ft²
  • 1 king bed
  • 1 king bed
Enter dates to see prices
Accessibility - Suite - 1 King Bed, Bathtub, Sofabed, Kitchen, Patio, Nonsmoking
...
  • Room size: 55 m²/592 ft²
  • 1 sofa bed and 1 king bed
  • 1 sofa bed and 1 king bed
Enter dates to see prices
2 Queen Beds, Nonsmoking, Marina View
...
  • Room size: 28 m²/301 ft²
  • Marina view
  • 2 queen beds
Enter dates to see prices
Suite - 1 King Bed, Nonsmoking, Marina View, Full Kitchen, Living Room, Patio, Sofabed
...
  • Room size: 55 m²/592 ft²
  • Marina view
  • 1 king bed and 1 sofa bed
Enter dates to see prices
Accessibility - Studio Suite - 2 Queen Beds, Roll-in Shower, View, Mini-suite, Nonsmoking
...
  • Room size: 55 m²/592 ft²
  • 2 queen beds
  • 2 queen beds
Enter dates to see prices

Frequently asked questions

Experience your trip the ideal way with a drink in your hand at Best Western Plus Island Palms Hotel & Marina's bar available right in front of your doorstep for when you need a drink or two.

While staying at Best Western Plus Island Palms Hotel & Marina, you can take pleasure in the swimming pool facility to get your day started the right way with a splash for a revitalizing morning or evening.

While remaining at Best Western Plus Island Palms Hotel & Marina, kick start your getaway by visiting the closest attraction in walking distance to the property such as Humphreys Concerts by the Bay.

Best Western Plus Island Palms Hotel & Marina's most popular month where verified visitors have stayed the most is in December.

Verified families with young children that have stayed at this property have given Best Western Plus Island Palms Hotel & Marina an average rating of 8.6. You can look up more comprehensive customer assessments and comments by filtering for a specific type of verified travelers down in the review section.

The nearest train, metro, or bus station is San Diego Old Town Station, 5127.72 m away from Best Western Plus Island Palms Hotel & Marina.

Best Western Plus Island Palms Hotel & Marina’s neighborhood is San Diego Intl. Airport which includes popular restaurants such as Bali Hai Restaurant, Point Loma Seafoods, and Mitch's Seafood.

Check-in is from 04:00 PM, and check-out is until 11:00 AM. You may request early check-in or late check-out during booking, subject to availability. Visitors checking in or out before or after the designated periods may be charged an additional fee.

More about Best Western Plus Island Palms Hotel & Marina

More about Best Western Plus Island Palms Hotel & Marina

Experience Coastal Comfort at Best Western Plus Island Palms Hotel & Marina in San Diego

Nestled along the picturesque waterfront of San Diego, the Best Western Plus Island Palms Hotel & Marina offers a perfect blend of seaside serenity and modern convenience. Guests can enjoy a warm and welcoming atmosphere with well-appointed rooms that provide stunning views of the marina and lush surroundings. Whether you're here for a relaxing getaway or an adventurous exploration of San Diego’s vibrant attractions, this hotel provides an ideal base for your stay. Check-in begins at 4:00 PM, allowing guests to settle in and unwind after their journey, while check-out is smoothly coordinated until 11:00 AM to ensure a leisurely departure. The hotel is family-friendly, welcoming children aged 3 to 17 free of charge, making it an excellent choice for travelers seeking a comfortable and accommodating environment for all ages. Discover the charm and hospitality of this coastal retreat and create unforgettable memories in sunny San Diego.

Relaxation and Entertainment at Best Western Plus Island Palms Hotel & Marina

Discover a perfect blend of leisure and entertainment at the Best Western Plus Island Palms Hotel & Marina. Unwind after a day of exploring San Diego with a refreshing drink at the on-site bar, where you can enjoy a variety of beverages in a lively and welcoming atmosphere. For ultimate relaxation, indulge in a soothing massage that rejuvenates your body and mind, providing a luxurious escape from everyday stress. Additionally, guests can unwind in the hot tub, immersing themselves in warm, bubbling waters that offer a calming retreat and a delightful way to enhance your stay.

Premier Sports Facilities at Best Western Plus Island Palms Hotel & Marina

Discover a range of excellent sports amenities designed to keep you active and energized during your stay at the Best Western Plus Island Palms Hotel & Marina. Guests can enjoy access to a fully equipped fitness center, perfect for maintaining your workout routine with modern equipment in a comfortable setting. For those who love outdoor activities, the hotel offers well-maintained tennis courts where you can engage in a friendly match or improve your game against the scenic backdrop of San Diego’s beautiful surroundings. Additionally, take a refreshing dip in the inviting outdoor pool, ideal for relaxing after a day of sports or sightseeing. Whether you're a fitness enthusiast or simply looking to unwind, these sports facilities provide the perfect way to stay active and enjoy your stay to the fullest.

Seamless Connectivity with Free Wi-Fi in Every Room

At Best Western Plus Island Palms Hotel & Marina, staying connected is effortless thanks to complimentary high-speed Wi-Fi available throughout the property. Whether you're relaxing in your room, enjoying a meal at the restaurant, or lounging by the pool, you can easily browse the internet, stay in touch with loved ones, or get work done without interruption. This convenient amenity ensures that guests have reliable and fast internet access at all times, making your stay more comfortable and productive.

Comfort and Convenience in Every Room at Best Western Plus Island Palms Hotel & Marina

Experience a blend of comfort and modern amenities in each thoughtfully designed room at Best Western Plus Island Palms Hotel & Marina. Stay cool and refreshed with efficient air conditioning, and enjoy your favorite shows on the flat-screen television equipped with satellite and cable channels. Many rooms feature a private balcony or terrace, offering a perfect spot to unwind while soaking in scenic views. For added convenience, each room provides a coffee and tea maker, refrigerator, and complimentary tea, ensuring you start your day energized and refreshed. Guests will also appreciate the well-appointed toiletries and a hair dryer, making personal grooming effortless. Stay informed and entertained with a daily newspaper delivered to your door, and enjoy the seamless blend of comfort and practicality that makes your stay truly memorable. Whether you're relaxing indoors or enjoying the outdoor space, every detail is designed to enhance your experience at this exceptional hotel.

Exceptional Dining Experience at Best Western Plus Island Palms Hotel & Marina

At the Best Western Plus Island Palms Hotel & Marina, guests are invited to indulge in a delightful culinary journey at the on-site restaurant, where a diverse menu features fresh, locally sourced ingredients. The restaurant offers a relaxed yet sophisticated atmosphere, perfect for enjoying breakfast, lunch, or dinner while taking in scenic views of the marina. Whether you're craving a hearty meal or a light snack, the menu is designed to satisfy a variety of tastes and preferences. The dining experience is further enhanced by attentive service and a welcoming ambiance, making it an ideal spot for both casual dining and special occasions. Guests can unwind with a refreshing beverage from the bar, complemented by stunning waterfront vistas. With its inviting setting and delectable offerings, the restaurant at Best Western Plus Island Palms Hotel & Marina promises a memorable culinary experience in the heart of San Diego.

Explore a Variety of Luxurious Room Options at Best Western Plus Island Palms Hotel & Marina

Discover an array of thoughtfully designed rooms at Best Western Plus Island Palms Hotel & Marina, tailored to meet diverse preferences and needs. Whether you're seeking the comfort of a room with two Queen Beds in the Casa Marina Building, a spacious Suite with a Marina View and full kitchen spanning 55 square meters, or a cozy Studio Suite with a King Bed and scenic vistas, there's an ideal space for every guest. For those desiring enhanced accessibility, options include rooms with roll-in showers and other features to ensure a comfortable stay. Booking your preferred room type through Agoda not only guarantees you the best available prices but also offers a hassle-free and seamless reservation experience. Enjoy peace of mind knowing that your accommodations are secured at competitive rates, allowing you to focus on enjoying the stunning surroundings and amenities of San Diego. With easy booking processes and exclusive deals, Agoda makes planning your perfect getaway effortless and economical.

Convenient Access to San Diego Intl. Airport from Best Western Plus Island Palms Hotel & Marina

Nestled just a short drive from San Diego International Airport, the Best Western Plus Island Palms Hotel & Marina offers travelers unparalleled convenience and ease of access to their flights. Whether you're arriving or departing, the hotel’s proximity to the airport ensures a stress-free transition, allowing you to maximize your time exploring the vibrant city or relaxing by the marina. The area around the airport is bustling with activity, featuring a variety of dining options, car rental services, and transportation hubs that make your travel experience seamless.

Seamless Journey from San Diego International Airport to Best Western Plus Island Palms Hotel & Marina

Travelers arriving at San Diego International Airport will find their journey to the Best Western Plus Island Palms Hotel & Marina both convenient and effortless. Located just a short 10-minute drive from the airport, the hotel is easily accessible via a variety of transportation options. Upon exiting the terminal, guests can opt for a quick taxi or rideshare service such as Uber or Lyft, which offer direct, hassle-free transfers straight to the hotel’s doorstep. For those preferring public transportation, the Metropolitan Transit System (MTS) provides bus services that connect the airport to nearby neighborhoods, with a brief walk or transfer to reach the hotel. Alternatively, rental car services are available at the airport for guests who wish to explore San Diego at their own pace, with ample parking facilities at the hotel for added convenience. No matter your choice, the journey from San Diego International Airport to this charming waterfront retreat promises a smooth start to your stay.

Discover Nearby Landmarks and Attractions from Best Western Plus Island Palms Hotel & Marina

Nestled in the vibrant coastal area of San Diego, the Best Western Plus Island Palms Hotel & Marina offers easy access to a variety of captivating landmarks and attractions. Just moments away, Point Loma provides stunning panoramic views of the Pacific Ocean and the San Diego skyline, making it a perfect spot for sightseeing and photography. For those interested in local culture and cuisine, Liberty Public Market is nearby, offering a diverse array of artisanal foods, unique shops, and lively entertainment options.

Nearby Culinary Delights for Every Taste

Just moments from Best Western Plus Island Palms Hotel & Marina, a diverse array of exceptional dining options awaits guests. For a sophisticated waterfront experience, indulge in the exquisite flavors at Coasterra and Tom Ham's Lighthouse, both offering stunning views alongside their gourmet menus. Seafood lovers will appreciate the renowned Bali Hai Restaurant and Island Prime, known for their fresh catches and elegant atmospheres. For a casual yet nostalgic vibe, Corvette Diner provides classic American comfort food in a lively setting. Beer enthusiasts can explore the innovative brews at Stone Brewing World Bistro & Gardens - Liberty Station, while Allegro Bistro offers a taste of Mediterranean cuisine. The Bay Club Bar and Grill and Blue Wave Bar & Grill serve up hearty meals and refreshing drinks, perfect for unwinding after a day of exploring San Diego. Whether you're craving fine dining or casual bites, these nearby restaurants promise a memorable culinary journey during your stay.

Nearby Shopping Landmarks

Just a short distance from the Best Western Plus Island Palms Hotel & Marina, guests can explore the vibrant San Diego Comic Art Gallery. This unique destination offers a captivating collection of comic art, graphic novels, and pop culture memorabilia, making it a must-visit for enthusiasts and casual visitors alike. Whether you're looking for a one-of-a-kind souvenir or simply want to immerse yourself in the creative world of comic art, this gallery provides an engaging shopping experience right in the heart of San Diego.

Affordable Luxury: Comparing Room Prices at Best Western Plus Island Palms Hotel & Marina and San Diego

Nestled along the scenic waterfront of San Diego, the Best Western Plus Island Palms Hotel & Marina offers a remarkable blend of comfort and value, with room prices typically ranging from $201 to $250. This pricing aligns perfectly with the average hotel room cost in San Diego, which also falls within the same range. Guests can expect to enjoy a luxurious experience without exceeding the typical budget for the city, making it an excellent choice for both leisure and business travelers.

Exceptional Comfort and Scenic Beauty at Best Western Plus Island Palms Hotel & Marina

Guests consistently praise Best Western Plus Island Palms Hotel & Marina for its immaculate cleanliness and friendly, attentive staff who go above and beyond to ensure a memorable stay. The beautifully appointed rooms, featuring exceptionally comfortable beds, provide a perfect retreat after a day of exploring the stunning surroundings. Visitors love the hotel's prime location, offering breathtaking views and easy access to nearby parks, making it an ideal spot for families and travelers alike. Many guests highlight the hotel’s picturesque setting, describing it as a truly beautiful location that enhances their overall experience. The spacious rooms with impressive vistas, combined with the peaceful marina ambiance, create a relaxing and enjoyable atmosphere. With positive reviews emphasizing the quality of the accommodations and the convenience of the location, guests frequently mention their intention to return, making Best Western Plus Island Palms Hotel & Marina a highly recommended choice for travelers seeking comfort and scenic charm in San Diego.

Exceptional Guest Experiences at Best Western Plus Island Palms Hotel & Marina

Guests consistently praise the Best Western Plus Island Palms Hotel & Marina for its outstanding overall quality, reflected in a high customer rating of 8.6. The hotel’s prime location in San Diego offers stunning waterfront views and convenient access to local attractions, earning an impressive score of 9.2 for its setting. Visitors appreciate the well-maintained facilities, which contribute to a comfortable and enjoyable stay, supported by a facility rating of 8.6 and exceptional cleanliness with a score of 8.9. The attentive staff further enhances guest experiences, demonstrating a high level of professionalism and friendliness that guests find truly welcoming. While the hotel excels in many areas, guests also value the good value for money, with an 8.5 rating, making it an attractive choice for both leisure and business travelers. Although there is room for improvement in food and dining, the overall positive atmosphere, combined with comfortable accommodations and excellent service, makes the Best Western Plus Island Palms Hotel & Marina a highly recommended destination for those seeking a memorable stay in San Diego.

Show less

Amenities and facilities

Excellent8.7

Facilities

Most talked about facilities

Languages spoken
  • English
Accessibility
  • Facilities for disabled guests
  • Visual alarms in some guest rooms and suites
  • Wheelchair accessible
Internet access
  • Free Wi-Fi in all rooms!
  • Internet
  • Internet services
  • Wi-Fi in public areas
Things to do, ways to relax
  • Computer station
  • Fishing
  • Fitness center
  • Garden
  • Gym/fitness
  • Hot tub
  • Massage
  • Spa
  • Spa/sauna
  • Swimming pool
  • Swimming pool [outdoor]
  • Tennis court
  • Tours
Cleanliness and safety
  • Anti-viral cleaning products
  • Breakfast takeaway service
  • Cashless payment service
  • First aid kit
  • Free face masks
  • Guest rooms seal after sanitization
  • Hand sanitizer
  • Hot water linen and laundry washing
  • Individually-wrapped food options
  • Physical distancing of at least 1 meter
  • Protective screens in common areas
  • Room sanitization opt-out available
  • Rooms sanitized between stays
  • Safe dining setup
  • Sanitized kitchen and tableware items
  • Shared stationery removed
  • Staff trained in safety protocol
Dining, drinking, and snacking
  • Bar
  • Restaurants
  • Room service
Services and conveniences
  • Air conditioning in public area
  • Cash withdrawal
  • Dry cleaning
  • Elevator unavailable
  • Heating in public area
  • Meeting/banquet facilities
  • Safety deposit boxes
  • Smoke-free property
  • Smoking area unavailable
  • Xerox/fax in business center
For the kids
  • Family/child friendly
  • Family room
  • Kids meal
Access
  • Check-in/out [express]
  • Front desk [24-hour]
  • Non-smoking rooms
  • Pets allowed unavailable
Getting around
  • Car park [on-site]
Available in all rooms
  • Air conditioning
  • Free bottled water unavailable
  • Hair dryer
  • In-room safe box
  • Interconnecting room(s) available
  • Microwave
  • Non-smoking
  • Refrigerator
  • Wake-up service

Food and dining

Breakfast options
  • Continental
Restaurants on site
Blue Wave Bar & Grill
  • Cuisine: American
  • Menu: Buffet

Location

2051 Shelter Island Drive, San Diego Intl. Airport, San Diego (CA), United States, 92106-3105

Exceptional9.2

Location

Airports
  • San Diego International Airport (SAN) - United States
    3.9 km
  • Tijuana International Airport (TIJ) - Mexico
    30.0 km
Public transportation
  • San Diego Old Town Station
    5.1 km
  • Old Town Transit Center Station
    5.3 km
Hospital or clinic
  • Urgent Care & More
    4.4 km
Shopping
  • Fashion Valley
    8.3 km
Convenience store
  • 7 Eleven
    1.9 km
Cash withdrawal
  • ATM
    500 m

What's nearby

Popular landmarks
  • USS Midway Museum
    4.9 km
  • Seaport Village
    5.3 km
  • Old Town San Diego State Historic Park
    5.4 km
  • SeaWorld
    5.7 km
  • Petco Park
    6.7 km
  • Coronado Bridge
    7.4 km
  • San Diego Zoo
    7.7 km
  • Balboa Park
    8.0 km
  • Torrey Pines State Natural Reserve
    24.8 km
Nearby landmarks
  • Humphreys Concerts by the Bay
    400 m
  • Japanese Friendship Bell
    840 m
  • Americas Cup Harbor
    880 m
  • YOLO Board San Diego
    920 m
  • Harbor and Shelter Islands
    960 m
  • Kellogg's Beach
    980 m
  • Eppig Brewing
    980 m
  • St Agnes Catholic Church
    1.2 km
  • Marine Corps Recruit Depot (MCRD) Airport
    1.4 km
  • Jensen's Foods
    1.9 km
Distances shown are straight-line distances on the map. Actual travel distances may vary.

Property policies

Children and extra beds

Extra beds are dependent on the room you choose. Please check the individual room capacity for more details.

All children are welcome.

Infant 0-2 year(s)
Stay for free if using existing bedding.
Baby cot/crib available upon request
Children 3-17 year(s)
Stay for free if using existing bedding.
If you need an extra bed, it will incur an additional charge.
Guests 18 years and older are considered as adults
Must use an extra bed which will incur an additional charge.
Others
  • When booking more than 5 rooms, different policies and additional supplements may apply.

Some helpful facts

Check-in/Check-out
  • Check-in from16:00
  • Check-out until11:00
Extras
  • Breakfast charge (unless included in room price)14 USD
Parking
  • Daily parking fee25 USD

Reviews of Best Western Plus Island Palms Hotel & Marina from real guests

tooltip

All ratings and comments on Agoda are from verified guests who must complete a stay before submitting a review.

Provided by verified guests of

Agoda logo
8.7

Excellent

Recent ratings trend

10 most recent verified ratings received by the property

  • 8.4
  • 8.4
  • 10
  • 8.8
  • 6.4
  • 9.6
  • 10
  • 10
  • 10
  • 9.2

Most recent

  • Location score 9.2 out of 10 and is a high score in San Diego (CA)
    Location9.2
  • Cleanliness score 8.9 out of 10 and is a high score in San Diego (CA)
    Cleanliness8.9
  • Service score 8.9 out of 10 and is a high score in San Diego (CA)
    Service8.9
  • Facilities score 8.7 out of 10 and is a high score in San Diego (CA)
    Facilities8.7
  • Value for money score 8.6 out of 10 and is a high score in San Diego (CA)
    Value for money8.6
  • Room comfort and quality score 7.3 out of 10
    Room comfort and quality7.3
High score for San Diego (CA)

Rating

9+ Exceptional (52)
8-9 Excellent (19)
7-8 Very Good (8)
6-7 Good (8)
<6 Below Expectation (9)
Guest Type
Room Type
Language

Show reviews that mention 

Location

Mentioned in 14 reviews
sentiment-positive-indicator
100% Positive

Cleanliness

Mentioned in 9 reviews
sentiment-positive-indicator
77% Positive
sentiment-negative-indicator
22% Unfavourable

Service

Mentioned in 8 reviews
sentiment-positive-indicator
87% Positive
sentiment-negative-indicator
12% Unfavourable

Room comfort

Mentioned in 7 reviews
sentiment-positive-indicator
85% Positive
sentiment-negative-indicator
14% Unfavourable

Room view

Mentioned in 5 reviews
sentiment-positive-indicator
100% Positive

Value for money

Mentioned in 5 reviews
sentiment-positive-indicator
40% Positive
sentiment-negative-indicator
60% Unfavourable

Pool

Mentioned in 4 reviews
sentiment-positive-indicator
100% Positive

Room size

Mentioned in 3 reviews
sentiment-positive-indicator
33% Positive
sentiment-negative-indicator
66% Unfavourable

Parking

Mentioned in 2 reviews
sentiment-positive-indicator
50% Positive
sentiment-negative-indicator
50% Unfavourable
Showing 96 verified guest comments
Changed to review page 1
  1. 10.0
    Exceptional
    Misael from Mexico
    Group
    2 Queen Beds, Nonsmoking, Casa Marina Building, Water View
    Stayed 1 night in January 2026

    “Exceptional stay experience”

    Amazing location if you’re going to take a flight from the SA airport, very clean, and friendly staff. Great facilities and excellent value for money. Highly recommended for a relaxing stay.

    Reviewed February 06, 2026
  2. 10.0
    Exceptional
    Mayra from Singapore
    Couple
    2 queen beds, nonsmoking
    Stayed 1 night in February 2026

    “Perfect Stay by the Marina”

    This place offers fantastic value for money with stunning views and a beautiful garden that makes it a perfect retreat. The cleanliness is impressive, and the staff are exceptionally friendly and helpful, enhancing the overall experience. Plus, the facilities cater to all needs, making it easy to relax or explore the nearby shopping and transport options. Highly recommend for a memorable getaway!

    Reviewed February 18, 2026
  3. 10.0
    Exceptional
    VALERIE from United States
    Solo traveler
    1 King Bed, Nonsmoking
    Stayed 1 night in December 2024

    “Great Place To Stay!”

    Though I only stayed for one night, I wish I my trip were longer. Upon arrival I was met with a warm and friendly front desk staff. They described the hotel's amenities and gave me clear directions to my room/building. The outdoor landscape was neatly manicured and the outside of the each building was clean and clear for guests to enter. My room was on the second floor. The room was clean and did not have any odors. I had a king sized bed which was comfortable and the temperature of the room was comfortable, even without having to turn on the heater. The bathroom was clean and the shower had dispensers for shower gel, shampoo and conditioner. My overnight stay was good and I look forward to staying there again if I'm in the area.

    Reviewed December 28, 2024
  4. 10.0
    Exceptional
    Janet from United States
    Solo traveler
    1 King Bed, Nonsmoking
    Stayed 1 night in June 2024

    “Wonderful place to stay on the Bay”

    Love this place. Sorry I could stay more than one night. This “historical “ hotel has been on Shelter Island since the early 1960s. It has several remodels and owners but as a Best Western Plus it excels. My room as quiet and comfortable. And the bed was just right. Large bathroom with walk in shower. I got a really good deal for the room at Agoda.com and everything was perfect. Was just in time for happy hour at the bar and had a delicious dinner in the Blue Wave Bar and Grill. All in all a great place to stay.

    Reviewed June 12, 2024
  5. 8.8
    Excellent
    Gracey from United States
    Family with young children
    2 Queen Beds, Nonsmoking, Marina View
    Stayed 2 nights in December 2025

    “Great hotel”

    Great location with a great view! The staff was wonderful. The room was very clean and comfortable.

    Reviewed December 07, 2025
Changed to review page 1

This is a popular property. Don't miss out!